The problem these days is that we have so many files and some of them are large as cameras get more megapixels or you shoot video. The good side is that storage get cheaper per gigabyte (soon we’ll be saying per terabyte.) No matter what, though, we probably end up with more than one device that we have to attach somehow, even in the case of laptops. In the early Mac days it was some kind of serial attachment that no one probably remembers anymore. Then came SCSI which was a cantankerous pain in the rear. Firewire was supposed to be our deliverance, being pretty fast and trouble free. However, the external housings were pricy, especially in the case of Firewire 800. The pain of discovering that your PATA Firewire 800 housing was now a dead end since SATA had take over the world was excruciating. USB came along shortly after Firewire and USB external housings proliferated like rabbit even though it seemed like a really bad idea. In spite of the spec. claims, USB is slow and the though of a terabyte USB drive is mind boggling. Price and convenience seem to be the driving factor with performance only of interest to hardcore users. The latest, but strangely not hyped, development is eSATA, or external SATA. eSATA is fast and cheap, but few seem to have heard about it, probably since eSATA ports don’t come stock on most computers, desk nor laptop.
Photography is the main driver for my storage needs these days. I’m also concerned about security, redundancy, and reliability in relation to certain Mac hardware issues. With the Mac Pro tower you have four internal bays for cramming in drives. On my G3 and G4 I’d already been doing this using PCI card controllers. Early G3 provided tray room for 3 drives and the G4s had room built in for 4. By the way, my Yukon Mac was the best and most reliable Mac I’ve ever had, living way beyond its design life and I hope it’s still running somewhere. Only the lack of compatibility with Leopard made me give it up.
The Mac G5 had only 2 drive bays, but after market kits allowed you to add at least 3 and sometimes more. The first SATA Mac, PCI cards allowed compatibility with older PATA drives. There was also a trick where you could tap into the CD drive harness to support a PATA drive. However, the power supply of the G5 started giving up under the load of so many drives. By the end, I could boot up with only one drive. I read somewhere that the failure rate of G5s was up to 25%, probably due to power supplies, a problem which has troubled other Mac models. Of course, there was also the jet engine fan problem.
Anyway, my G5 problems started me thinking about more dependence on external drives. I’d had some early firewire 400 housings, but these were limited to 120 gigabytes due to the early controllers. Looking for a better soluiton, I went to firewire 800 dual housings that supported RAID. The first ones I got supported PATA, of course. These types of housings were not easy to find and there was really only one online vendor, operating under different names. Of course, I am talking about a consumer type housing. There are plenty of firewire 800 housings if you are looking for something really expensive intended for commercial applications. SATA versions were even rarer and more expensive. I spent the money and ended up with 3 PATA and one SATA, although one was an unintentional buy. On one order the vendor sent me an extra drive, and I ended up buying it since straightening things out was a mess. The vendor was a jerk about the issue and I think I ended up being blackballed by them, which cut off my future access to firewire 800 RAID drives.
At the same time as I was making this transition, I gave away my ailing G5 and picked up a Mac Pro. Originally I did fill up all four bays. However, I started worrying about security and wanted the option of being able to lock up most of my drives physically. I had my Firewire 800 drives, but 3 of them were dead ends since PATA drives stopped at around 750 megabytes and future availability seemed uncertain. One thing I know is that my storage requirements always grow. I also started worrying more about backups and started using Timemachine. I also like maintaining a lot of headroom on my drives.
Firewire 800 is almost as fast as internal SATA, but the cost is too high. I wasn’t going to convert over to all SATA RAID housings. Compatibility isn’t that great since only the Mac Pros and the 15“ and larger Mac laptops support it. The writing is also on the wall that Apple is dropping support of Firewire, which is the killer. New 13” Macbooks don’t even have a firewire 400 port.
While researching how to put a bigger drive in what was at that time my Mom’s Mac Mini, I started reading about eSATA. Sure enough, a PCI-X eSATA card was available for my Mac Pro, as wel as a ExpressCard 34 for my 15“ Macbook Pro laptop. I gave up on fast external disc solutions for my 13” MacBooks since one only has USB and the other only Firewire 400. The cards are relatively cheap ($60 late 2008) and the external eSATA housings are much cheaper than firewire ones, only a little more than USB ones. Single drive eSATA housings are readily available in brick and mortar stores, since they usually also support USB. A $75 dual drive housing is available from macsales.com. Although I initially went with a hardware card for my Mac Pro for convenience, Apple actually supplies two unused eSATA ports in the MacPros. It’s a trick getting to them, but after I decided that I liked eSATA, I decided to tap into them. The kit for doing this (Newer Technology http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Newer%20Technology/MPQXES2/), which provides cables and female ports that go where a PCI card should go, is only around $25. One hitch is that drives hooked up to the internal ports are not how swappable. They behave just like internal drives.
You’re supposed to disassemble half your Mac to get at the ports, but I’d read on the net that it can be done without disassembly if you’re very careful and patient. Whatever else I like about the eSATA, I have to admit that the connectors are not user friendly, even under the best of circumstances. I did use a pair of large angled tweezers. On the forums they recommended forceps. I ended up bending back part of a fan housing to ease getting access.
With the Newer kit that gives you 2 ports and I also have 2 on the PCI-X card I installed. Only the
PCI-X card supports hot swapping. It is possible to get more expensive cards ($200+) that support multiple port enclosures, so that you can attach up to 20 drives at one time.
Currently I have a single 1.5 terabyte drive in the Mac Pro housing. The rest of my drives are in two double eSATA housings plus singles that I swap in as needed. One drive I clone from my boot disk. One of my old Firewire 800 RAID housings I use for Timemachine. That one supports SATA so it has a future. There’s another Firewire 800 RAID housing I use for general purpose use. That one only supports PATA so its future is limited. Mostly I use just the boot drive.
I’d also like some backup in the clouds. I subscribed to mac.com, but the transition to me.com ticked me off, so I’m dropping that. Storage is also limited and expensive.I signed up with mozy.com, but I was never able to get it to make a complete backup. It always had some kind of error. A colleague who did get it to backup said that it was very hard to recall any files from mozy. In the forums I read that other people have had the same experience. When I quit mozy, they did not refund any part of the two year fee I paid. They didn’t respond to my email and there doesn’t seem to be a number to call. I’ve noticed that the cloud backup world seems to be pretty tough since some of the vendors have gone out of business. I’m still looking.